How Is a CMA Built?
Pick comparables
The agent selects recent sales near the subject with similar size, age, condition and lot.
Adjust for differences
Differences in square footage, condition or features are adjusted to compare like with like.
Weigh the market
Active and expired listings show what buyers did not accept, which helps frame the range.
Give a range
The result is a value range with reasoning, not a single guaranteed price.
A Simple Example
| Comparable | Sale Price | Square Feet | Price per Sq Ft |
|---|---|---|---|
| Comp A | $900,000 | 1,900 | $474 |
| Comp B | $860,000 | 1,750 | $491 |
| Comp C | $925,000 | 1,950 | $474 |
Applying $474 to $491 per square foot to 1,800 square feet gives a rough range of about $853,000 to $885,000. A real CMA also adjusts for condition, lot, upgrades and timing, so treat this as a simplified picture.
Want a CMA before you price or offer? Ask Roman for one.
Get My Free EstimateCMA vs. Appraisal
CMA
An agent's market-based opinion. Used for pricing a listing or evaluating an offer.
Appraisal
A licensed, independent valuation. Lenders require it for financing.
They can differ
If an appraisal comes in below your price, the appraisal contingency matters.
What Should You Ask About a CMA?
Ask for
- Which comparable sales were used and when they closed
- How adjustments were made
- The value range, not one number
Be careful when
- Comps are old or far away
- Few comps exist in a fast-moving market
- The range looks out of line with what you see
- 1Request the CMABefore pricing or offering
- 2Review the compsRecency, distance and condition
- 3Test the rangeAgainst listings you tour
- 4Get a second lookIf it seems off
Roman prepares a CMA for buyers evaluating an offer and for sellers before listing. See flat fee agent for how he works.