Home› Glossary› Comparative Market Analysis (CMA)
Glossary · Real Estate Terms

Comparative Market Analysis (CMA)

A comparative market analysis (CMA) is an agent-prepared report that estimates a property's value by comparing it to similar homes that recently sold, are currently listed, or were listed but did not sell nearby. It is an opinion of value used for pricing and offers, not a formal appraisal.

How Is a CMA Built?

Pick comparables

Similar homes nearby

The agent selects recent sales near the subject with similar size, age, condition and lot.

Adjust for differences

Size, upgrades, lot

Differences in square footage, condition or features are adjusted to compare like with like.

Weigh the market

Sold, active, expired

Active and expired listings show what buyers did not accept, which helps frame the range.

Give a range

Not one number

The result is a value range with reasoning, not a single guaranteed price.

A Simple Example

Illustration only. A 1,800 square foot home. Three nearby sales are compared on price per square foot.
ComparableSale PriceSquare FeetPrice per Sq Ft
Comp A$900,0001,900$474
Comp B$860,0001,750$491
Comp C$925,0001,950$474

Applying $474 to $491 per square foot to 1,800 square feet gives a rough range of about $853,000 to $885,000. A real CMA also adjusts for condition, lot, upgrades and timing, so treat this as a simplified picture.

Want a CMA before you price or offer? Ask Roman for one.

Get My Free Estimate

CMA vs. Appraisal

CMA

An agent's market-based opinion. Used for pricing a listing or evaluating an offer.

Appraisal

A licensed, independent valuation. Lenders require it for financing.

They can differ

If an appraisal comes in below your price, the appraisal contingency matters.

What Should You Ask About a CMA?

Ask for

  • Which comparable sales were used and when they closed
  • How adjustments were made
  • The value range, not one number

Be careful when

  • Comps are old or far away
  • Few comps exist in a fast-moving market
  • The range looks out of line with what you see
  1. 1
    Request the CMABefore pricing or offering
  2. 2
    Review the compsRecency, distance and condition
  3. 3
    Test the rangeAgainst listings you tour
  4. 4
    Get a second lookIf it seems off

Roman prepares a CMA for buyers evaluating an offer and for sellers before listing. See flat fee agent for how he works.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a comparative market analysis?
An agent-prepared report that estimates a property's market value by comparing it to similar homes that sold recently, are currently listed, or were listed but did not sell nearby.
Is a CMA the same as an appraisal?
No. A CMA is an agent's market-based opinion used for pricing or negotiation. An appraisal is a formal, licensed valuation that lenders require, and only an appraisal determines the value your lender uses.
How many comparable sales are used?
There is no fixed number. Agents usually choose recent nearby sales that are similar in size, age and condition. Fewer or older comps make a CMA less reliable, especially in fast-moving markets.
How far back do comps go?
It depends on the market. In active markets agents lean on recent sales, because older sales may not reflect current conditions. Ask which sales were used and when they closed.
Can a CMA be wrong?
Yes. It is an opinion, and it can miss condition, view or timing differences. Use the range, not a single number, and get a second opinion if it seems off.
Do buyers use CMAs?
Yes. Buyers use them to evaluate whether an offer price is reasonable and to prepare for a possible low appraisal.
Does Roman provide a CMA?
Yes. Ask for one before pricing a listing or making an offer.